Did you have any balance problems before you changed tires? If not, your wheels are likely within specification. You know if you have abused the wheels - so be straight with yourself there. Are you using tires the same size as OEM? Larger tires are harder to balance.
If you have choices, get to a dealer (tire or Dodge) with a road force balance machine. All wheels are out of round and so are all tires. If the wheels are within specification and the tires are as well (i. e. +/- the correct amount which I do not know), the road force machine will assist the dealer in "clocking" the combination of wheel and tire to achieve the best balance between wheel and tire, then perform a balance on the combination.
Good luck - this is a hard problem to solve. It's worse if the tire dealer wants to sell you wheels. Ask yourself what the chances are of all six of your wheels being suddenly bad???