AGAIN, ABSOLUTELY!
Commodities trading is to smooth out peaks and valleys in (gasp!) COMMODITIES, such as wheat and other SEASONAL agricultural products.
Crude oil is pumped, bought, transported, and refined as FAST as it is available to the refiners 24/7/365 - so HOW can any thinking person profess the traders are performing ANY "valuable service to society", other than fattening their own bank accounts?

Gary,
Easy Bro, Lets not form up a lynch mob just yet.
... . I'm on your side.
There is blame to be placed, but who are the manipulators "Exactly" ?
As I said earlier ... . traders perform a service... . they provide "LIQUIDITY" to the market... that includes day traders..... you'd play hell getting a good fill price without them.
Liquidity does not mean that it smoths out peaks and valleys... . I didn't say that.
There's all sorts of traders... .competing with each other... . on all sorts of time frames.
Long term short term, day.
Speculation is a global pastime... . that's why Las Vegas exists.
But it doesn't change..... SUPPLY & DEMAND !
As you yourself make the point..... oil is pumped transported and sold as fast as possible.....
That is
DEMAND ! It's demand that drives prices.
If there's enough oil..... then who's holding it back ? and why ?
And who is big oil ?
Rockerfeller is quoted as saying..... Competition is a
SIN ! Think about that.
... . Chase Manhattan is the bank Rockerfeller founded..... but there are others, JP Morgan etc.
They conspire... . so as not to compete.
Of course they were buying tons of contracts once they had their plan in place.
Hedge funds blow up all the time, as you know.
One may want to read the history of LTCM (Long Term Capital Management).
A bunch of top Scientists and Nobel prize winning economists formed up and blew up
the fund because they couldn't manage risk.
Then who bails em out ? The Federal Reserve... . ( that means US ..... ultimately ).
Like I said... . I'm with you... . there are culprits here... . there is conspiracy.
But I suggest we take another look.
If we want to point to the cause... ...
I respectfully submit that one takes a look at the well documented and
publically available... . History of the Federal Reserve.
The Federal Reserve is no more Federal than ... ... Federal Express ... a deceptive name
..... it is emphatically ..... a private International Banking Cartel.
And we peons are the sheep for the shearing.
Our legislators put them in charge of our money a long time ago..... offically so in 1913.
Much like putting Dracula in charge of the Blood Bank !
Follow the money trail and it'll take you to the truth everytime.
Where's the money... ..... in the internationalists banks.
The Golden Rule is: He who has the Gold makes the Rules !
Who has the Gold ... ..... The FED !
And their long term investment has been doing quite well lately eh?
I wish all Americans would read the book... .
The Creature from Jekyll Island... . by Griffin.
Hope this link works to Amazon.
Amazon.com: The creature from jekyll island: Books
You know, I'm just an old cowboy trying to figure all this stuff out over the years..... because when I was a young Marine in Vietnam (65, 66, 68), I remember seeing pallets and pallets of Anaconda Copper sheet sitting on the beach..... and what did we do with it ?... ... . we ROOFED our living quarters with it ... ...
I smelled a Rat... ... . The Lords of War created the
DEMAND ! ( when there was no real demand ).
If things get bad enough..... we'll eventually all have another revolution of some kind..... when the little guy gets squeezed to the point of unbearable... ... like you say the "Let em eat cake" point. .
I always try to be opened minded about any point... I love to be proven wrong.
In this case, I'd love to be proven wrong..... Maybe I'd sleep better at nights.
Most people don't seem to realize just how really really bad it is !
It's
Terrifying !
BTW: The April Crude oil contract closed at $108 today ( Monday 3. 10. 08 ).
... ... ... Gold at... . $975 oz.
And that's not the price of things going up... . it's the value of our dollar going down.
Me I just try to be of good cheer and make someones day a little better if possible.
That's all we got.
And a parting quote:
The Law locks up both man and woman,
Who steals the goose from off the common.
But lets the greater felon loose,
Who steals the common from the goose.
Happy Trails
Ray
.