Hey Trevor;
Good to hear it wasn't a cracked timing case.
Were you expecting to see the pin sticking out as on that old 90 at Ramsey Dyno Day in October?
I've had great luck reusing old gaskets by giving them a cleanup with acetone or alcohol and painting lightly with Permatex Aviation formula gasket maker.
I usually put a dab of RTV around the metal part of seals. Really important on axle seals as the hole isn't always perfect and that is a big cause of leaks.
-John