At work, we have a '99 F350 7. 3 Power Stroke with a 6-spd. Would we buy another Power Stroke with a manual transmission? No way. A 6. 0 with an automatic? Possibly.
We test-drove an early '99 Ford with an automatic. It was OK, nothing special. My head & heart both told me that this in no real I-6 diesel. (What's with that weird "marbles spinning in a coffee can" sound?) But, when the decision was made to order a truck, the two Blue Ovals (my brother & father) overruled my vote. In the Ford's defense, it has a good-handling chassis (2wd) and is solid except for the shaky Super Cab doors.
My criticism of the Power Stroke? It has no guts down low with a manual transmission. Very sluggish below 2000 rpm in 1st & 2nd. Get past 2 grand and then the power comes on like a light switch. We are convinced that there is a torque-limiting code in the CPU that reduces the power. So much for the torque peak at 1800 rpm.
It is scary making a quick, left turn in front of traffic... a hole in traffic, GO... I hope this thing makes it... car getting closer... Oh shoot, I'm dead... OFF LIKE A ROCKET!
My bone stock, '98 2500 24v is much easier to drive than the '99 Ford. A very liveable drivetrain. The Power Stroke with the manual requires more mental attention to the job at hand.
Will my Cummins beat a Power Stroke in a race? No, but that's not why I bought my truck. I get 5 mpg more than most Power Stokes.
Recently, I drove an 2004 F450 6. 0 automatic. It was 4wd with a large 12-ft. aluminum bed. It was a heavy truck, but quite snappy. I was impressed with the way the 6. 0/Torque Shift combo drove. But, test drives do not make a reliable truck.
Last week, the owner of the aforementioned 6. 0 & I drove 600 miles back from the Indianapolis F1 race in my Dodge. While we were in Indy, he had received a call from one of his employees that the 6. 0 blew an intake hose, losing all boost. (Power Stroke costing him downtime. ) After listening to my Cummins purr for several hours, he started verbally beating himself up for buying the 6. 0 and said he ought to sell it. I told him not to fret over it... then I let the Cummins continue with its sermon!