ROCK KRIES,
I've seen my trip computer range from 0. 2 OVER my actual mileage, up to 1. 5 UNDER. Most often it is about 0. 5 to 0. 7 under. But consider this: Your mileage, calculated the old way, can be off by more than 1 mpg just because at station #1 you parked on a left-slope while at station #2 you were on a right slope, or, because the fuel foamed more that day or you filled it all the way up the neck. Also, errors will be greater on "partial" tank fill ups. If you only bought ~$10 worth, then $0. 50 more (an amount I can always squeeze in by waiting for the foam to subside) represents a 5% error in the calculation. On a $40 fill up, this same extra $0. 50 only causes a 1. 25% error. Given all the potential sources of error, I feel at least some of the error we all see on INDIVIDUAL fill-ups is really in our CALCULATED mileage, and I don't think it is fair to assume it is always totally "computer" error. That said, if you average over several tanks, or hundreds of miles, then the manually calculated mileage is going to be very, very accurate.
I find that the real value of the trip computer is not for calculating the mpg at the end of the trip. What makes it a valuable gauge is the "instantaneous" readings that allow you to fine tune your driving style to maximize mpg. If yours generally reads a little low but is consistent, I would not worry about getting it calibrated. It's not worth the risk of letting someone else under your hood!
JOMO
------------------
2001 ETH, QC, LWB, 4WD, 3. 54, SPA Pyro & Boost, Leer Cab-high shell, ARB's soon
I've seen my trip computer range from 0. 2 OVER my actual mileage, up to 1. 5 UNDER. Most often it is about 0. 5 to 0. 7 under. But consider this: Your mileage, calculated the old way, can be off by more than 1 mpg just because at station #1 you parked on a left-slope while at station #2 you were on a right slope, or, because the fuel foamed more that day or you filled it all the way up the neck. Also, errors will be greater on "partial" tank fill ups. If you only bought ~$10 worth, then $0. 50 more (an amount I can always squeeze in by waiting for the foam to subside) represents a 5% error in the calculation. On a $40 fill up, this same extra $0. 50 only causes a 1. 25% error. Given all the potential sources of error, I feel at least some of the error we all see on INDIVIDUAL fill-ups is really in our CALCULATED mileage, and I don't think it is fair to assume it is always totally "computer" error. That said, if you average over several tanks, or hundreds of miles, then the manually calculated mileage is going to be very, very accurate.
I find that the real value of the trip computer is not for calculating the mpg at the end of the trip. What makes it a valuable gauge is the "instantaneous" readings that allow you to fine tune your driving style to maximize mpg. If yours generally reads a little low but is consistent, I would not worry about getting it calibrated. It's not worth the risk of letting someone else under your hood!
JOMO
------------------
2001 ETH, QC, LWB, 4WD, 3. 54, SPA Pyro & Boost, Leer Cab-high shell, ARB's soon