Originally posted by Lhotka
PowerWagon,
Thanks for your OPINION, That's all it is. Two thousand acres may be the size of the development area that is being proposed, but under the pretences that it will impact an area no larger. That's like having an airport 2 blocks away from your home and saying it only impacts the ground it physically covers. Purely nonsense. You don't understand or appreciate the very simple concept that many people value limited preservation over industrial development. Some refer to that as tunnel vision.
Of course it's my OPINION... You are expressing yours as well. But, what I'm asking for is some intellectual honesty. IF this area had never been declared part of some far-off, unseen, and generally obscure wildlife reserve, would you be so totally against drilling there? I doubt it.
So, what is it, then, that congress drawing a line in the swamp does that makes it so "sacred" or "holy" and now so horrible to "defile" (although it doesn't)?
As for the "airport in my backyard" analogy... it's a bit flawed. For instance, it is the size of a couple airports out of an area larger than a lot of states. Also, it's not an airport. It's not going to result in massive activity. It's not going to result in huge human traffic, massive environmental destruction or disturbance. Further, as I said in the first post in this long thread... There's nothing there worth messing with anyway. Thats the funny part of all this: There are things worth saving, and things not. Mosquitoes and the bugs that invade the noses of the caribou... . well, they are not. The Caribou? Sure, but they aren't endangered, and especially not by drilling.
So, what IS endangered? Noone has made a case yet. So far, the arguments are: 1. It will enrich oil companies. 2. It will enrich oil companies. 3. It will enrich oil companies.
I've seen this type of argument before. In fact, I've heard it a lot. The last time I dealt with it, I spanked my younger son for making a similar whine. He has no cause to complain when someone else gets something he doesn't. Nor do we have any cause to complain if someone makes money. Nor is preventing someone else from making money a legitemate reason for anything. Envy is ugly from any angle.