No, not really idiotic. In context of today's malfunctions and design defects this is a serious concern and needs to be an alternative. Airbags are NOT working as expected by randomly going off, detonating, or not working at all when needed. All of a sudden it come to light of the past 15 years we have dead bodies piling up over airbags where the past was a smaller pile. We have parts suppliers and typical bean counters at car companies wanting to save a buck. Currently no one in our Government has the balls to stand up and say "Quit using unstable Ammonium Nitrate in airbags" by making this substance illegal for airbag use. (Yeah, that's what it is going to take to prevent some cheap supplier being a low bidder and continuing to use it.) Why not? Cost to OEM's? The wiring and unintended deployment is really 2nd order of magnitude compared to that. GM has the privilege of being first in this 'ongoing airbag scare with no end in sight' over their unintended ignition key rotation that shuts off your engine and disables the airbags in a car that isn't survivable without them working.
It's time we look hard at CAFE and quit designing or accepting "Coffins on wheels" for vehicles. Bring back the 5MPH bumper standard.
Having a "First class front row seat" to watching family survive a near fatal accident in a midsize car where the airbag was the reason it wasn't fatal combined with seat belt use, well, we have come to the conclusion that the car was too damned small rather than giving credit to the airbag. The airbag, although helped, did shatter their bones in the hand and make their face look like Uncle Fester as well as word loss concussion. The 1980's van that caused the head on didn't have air bags and they all walked away. 4 years and 26+ surgeries later they are finally back to work, but, will never be the same suffering for the rest of their life from it.
So when I say 6 MPG at $6.00 a gal for fuel is fine with me it's only because the medical cost of the above would allow over for over 1 million miles at that MPG and fuel cost easily. It's be an inconvenient truth to do a study not done of small coffin on wheels vs a bigger container vehicle including Elk...