I run my lugs dry and reasonably clean, and lube my bolt a little. It gets nasty, but that's calculated in the design, IMO. I've run Lubriplate, powdered graphite, Slide-Glide, Kroil (several types), Friction Defense, several synthetics such as RemOil, FrogLube, motor oil, gear oil, and just plain high-temp grease... ... The powdered graphite definitely scares me, as it gets everywhere, and really doesn't seem to do much good... . unless it's got a light coat of oil for it to stick to!!! RemOil and such is OK in extreme cold, but the Lubriplate and gun grease really aren't worth a dang in the cold, and attract wayyyy too much dirt and dust. I've seen several guys swear by the Slip2000, perhaps due to that article... . I don't recall ever using it. One of the best I've seen for long term carry and mild usage is the Brownell's Friction Defense... . I really like it, and it seems like I don't see much wear. I don't do extended firing session with it, though. I usually pull my bolt and wipe it down with a good solvent or spray it every 50-100 rounds, depending on where I've been and how the weather has been. Dusty weather and carry conditions dictate a quicker cleaning interval for me. I can't stand that dust in the action. And around here, I'll drag the thing all over the place, in the seat, out the window, on foot, and on the tractor for days at a time. The sand
HAS to be cleaned out of it every week or two, or it'll really eat it up. In the summer, the Lubriplate and Troco "98" rule for wear, IMO, at the range and match shooting. It seems to just absorb the carbon, and wipes right out on Monday, after the normal 150+ rounds across the weekend course. But on the ranch, where I actually USE these things, the Friction Defense rules.
Interestingly, the low-viscosity engine oil works ok for wear, but don't trust it... . It'll burn a little easier than oil made specifically for firearms.....

:-laf