I had better luck with Dunlop Mud Rovers vs the BFG muds. BFG's get all the ratings for sidewall strength, etc, but in real life use, the dunlops gave better overall service, drivability on road, reliability (never had a tear or puncture, (vs both sets of BFG muds had a flat or two), and life from my past personal experiences.
Now, am pretty satisfied with the "compromise" of the 285/75 BFG all terrains. They seem to last forever and not too wide for snow, rain, etc. They just suck in mud and fling rocks on your paint, but the size seems to work out well on stock wheels, and they are a decent tire.
Seems to me i read that BFG is just a name now because they were bought by another major mfg, just don't rember the details. That is probably why the quality of the muds aren't like they used to be in the days when Ivan the Ironman was king.