I did a tire rotation on my truck tonight. As always, whenever I have a tire off for any reason I do a thorough check of all steering/suspension/brake components. This thread came to mind which prompted me to look with more scrutiny than normal.
For those that don't know I came from a gen 2 which I owned for 15+ years and had a VERY positive ownership with, so this is what I have based my experiences on. I don't have the long term review to offer of this truck but I've gotta tell ya, this truck is so much more truck than my 98 in every single way. Just looking at all the criticals, axles, control arms, tie rods, stabilizer, shocks, springs, leafs, brakes, etc. etc. etc. The list is continuous .More power, more refined, 2 extra gears, an integratrd exhaust brake, etc. etc. etc. Interior is more comfortable, quieter, steering and brakes are more responsive and crisp, etc. etc. See a pattern? I can not think of a single area I miss my 98, except perhaps the simplistic nature...but then again that is what makes this truck what it is. People on this forum give the 68rfe a bit of a bad rap but after 200k+ miles of towing with a 4 speed I'm sold . I've had a 110 horse Case IH on the hook multiple times and it's been flawless along with the exhaust brake. Haul the wheelers to West Virginia every year and my buddy in his 13 Silverado struggles to keep up on the grades. With a lighter load no less. We haul our 30ft 5th wheel on several long distance hauls through the summer. I dont do as much towing as some on here do but I do enough to know this pickup truck is the real deal when it comes to moving a load down the road. At 93k miles the original brake pads are still better than 50%. All front end components are also original and tire wear is excellent. I consider this pretty impressive given the poor secondary roads and fields I'm always in and percentage of towing.
I will say the A/C is sub par IMO in 95 degree heat and so is the heat when it's below zero. They both work but really no better than my 98 which is a fail in my book considering they had 16 years to improve upon something.
I had the DEF injector fail at around 85k miles. Other than that the emissions has been flawless. If and when it becomes a liability I'll take the sawzall to it and keep on keepin' on. After thinking about this thread through my tire rotation, I feel the need to stick up for the gen 4's. I've got a Tradesman so can't speak of all the foo foo stuff. But at least as far as the mechanicals are concerned, my 14 is light years above and beyond my 98. Never thought I'd say it, but I don't miss it a bit...at least not yet. I can only hope I have the same opinion 10 years from now.