Easy guys, I was only implying that Lake City brass is made to the same QUALITY STANDARDS as Federal... . As to the case thickness, typically, the cases vary lot to lot, by material, and by process. Drawn cases tend to be more consistent in thickness, while extruded cases are a bit cheaper to make... . Lupua and Norma are benchrest quality brass, while Lake City and Federal are not necessarily as consistent. Typically, while loading for match shooting, 99 out of 100 Lapua cartridges will be within the 5% wieght criteria I like for accuracy. This helps give me a standard deviation in velocities ranging around 4-10fps..... That really helps reduce vertical stringing, which makes it up to me to get the windage right.
For the 284s I've been using in matches, Winchester brand is the only . 284Win cartridge available... ... . I usually end up with about 40-50% failure to meet wieght each 100rnds of brass... . It's gotten so bad, I weigh it in 3-4 categories, putting the light brass in one box, the heavy in another, and keeping them for later use when I get 100+ rounds to reload..... or maybe for a hunting rifle. Even then, there are a few you'll notice that give you erratic FPS readings, and typically, they'll fail after 3-4 reloads..... The bases are thicker, is my guess, so the thinner walls and neck fail from heat and stress..... that's a guess...
Federal is much better brass, and if you use it for match, you'll find about the same failure rate (wieght wise) as Lake City, which in my experience is around 20%, sometimes a little less. I used the Lake City brass in . 223 shooting a heavy AR "across the course"... . it roughed up my Lapua brass too much, so I started using Lake City... ..... Decent results, but you won't find my name on a wall anywhere.....
Lately, I've been "cheating" some 6. 5x284 brass into . 284 brass. It hurts the life of the brass, but the consistentcy is a little better..... Also been doing the same for . 260, using . 243 brass. I really don't like having the wrong headstamp on it, though..... Several of us have been petitioning Lapua to make . 284 brass for two years..... Maybe they'll hear us this year!!
