Well Rampage, you are in luck! Ever heard of CertiFit? They sell ONLY NEW body and trim parts (hoods, mirrors, headlights, tailgates, trim pieces, grilles, bumpers, etc)
A great place my local junk yard told me about.
I picked up a NEW 95 Silverado (was helping a friend with his wrecked truck) hood for $69. 00, and a NEW passenger side front fender for $35. 00

The parts are primed and everything, you can't tell a difference between them and an OEM part! I found 1 imperfection in the primer of the hood, was a simple fix with some sanding... In the store they have a display comparing (have the actual OEM and CertiFit part side by side) OEM parts to CertiFit parts, you will be impressed!
You should be able to get your part(s) for near nothing, and they have a location in your area (Chicago, right?).
HERE is the link for the Chicago location.
ADDRESS:
90 South Addison Road
Addison, IL 60101-3870
I am in no way associated with CertiFit, I am just a VERY satisfied customer of the Houston, Texas location... .
If you buy from them please post your thoughts about them (Just curious of others opinions of them)
BTW, they keep most of their parts in stock
