The more I think about it, there should be no difference if the key was cut by the dealership, or by you rubbing it between 2 rocks. The more I thought about it, I actually wanted to know the REAL answer, so I called my local Dodge dealer…. here's what I found out…
As noted above, the key (bought at Wal-Mart, from the dealer, or made in your shop) does not matter. The door key is NOT a Sentry key so it will not start your engine. The reason your alarm is sounding is because you are locking your truck with the Sentry key (which activates that alarm) then when you use the “door only” key to unlock the door, you have no way of de-activating that alarm. I usually turn my truck off, hide my ignition key, and manually lock the doors by pushing the door lock button. That way I DO NOT activate my alarm. Give it a try and let me know if this helps…
Now MillerR: I also asked about how to turn off the “reverse with door open alarm”, they said that they are unable to turn that off. Does anyone know of a sequence I can do to get that darn alarm to stop activating?