I replaced my damper with a stock damper last year at 110k miles. Wished I had done it at 70k because it really made a difference. I had driveline vibration at low rpm, rattling at low rpm under load, like when starting off at idle or idling up a parking garage ramp, and the engine would shake at idle. I had intermittent vibration at speed from 50 to 70 mph that would rattle your teeth. I replaced the driveshaft carrier bearing and u-joints and rebalance the tires with no change. My truck is a 6 speed so I could feel vibration and oscillation in the shifter. My damper didn't look bad so I was skeptical, glad I changed it. Now truck runs smooth at idle, low speed, and highway speeds. It even shifts better. I couldn't spend the extra dollars on a fluid damper especially since I wasn't sure it would fix the problem so went with a stock damper for $200.