I wanted a 1st Gen. Boxy styling. No-nonsense interior. And most importantly to me MANUAL front hubs and no stupid axle-disconnect.
Other half: "Those are ugly... get one like [her brother] has... "
Guess who won...
The other issue is 2nd Gen models are more common and thus easier to find in decent condition for a reasonable price. The only 1st gen that met my specs (4x4, Club Cab, 5 spd, and in a color that doesn't offend the woman) sold on Ebay for well over $10K last year and it still needed some TLC. My recently purchased '95 needed some mechanical TLC, has some miles on it, but the body and chassis are solid, cost me $9000.
YMMV.