Fisher- Nice with the cutting edge that trips but if you hit a big pile of snow you want it to trip down also.
Meyer / Diamond - They are ok I got a deal on mine that I coudlnt pass up but im ditching it for a Boss 8'6" poly V with locking cylinders. they meyers are a good nice looking plow and easy hookup (classic II) the classic I are the ones that the lights/pump are put on and you can drop your plow easy but the lights/pump stay on. (thats ok but a pain)
Western - really nice heavy duty! theyve got a shock on the A-frame to the plow so when it trips down it doesnt slam back as hard, The pro series is nice as well as the western 4 pin hook up, not quite as easy as the boss RT3 or meyer classic II, but the wester hookup is still quick and easy although the stand will get packed with ice/snow and its a little bit of a pain to get out if your taking the plow off.
Boss - RT3 hookup is FAST and easy pull up to the truck, plug it in, and push a button how hard is that! they are very strong, look good, the lights are bright! and it comes in a cutting edge trip, poly or steel, as well as the obvious V plow that they are known for. The downside is that the V is heavy, especially the 9'2"! but extremely nice! Id say its the Bently of the snow plows!
non commercial its either Meyer, wester, or boss (if you can find a good one used) so Meyer(classic II) or Western (uni-mount) the meyer is quicker to hook up, but the western is a bit more stout and the shock really helps! Ive not had a problem yet with my meyer, but my western the 12 Pin connection on the plow side rotted a little and the lights werent working correctly so i had to buy a complete new harness for the plow (around 70. 00) I wasnt too thrilled with that. My cousin/boss has a 9'2" Boss V and I steal it when I can. It is the RT2 which is a little bit harder to put on than the RT3 but still somewhat easy.
Curtis and the others... sold cheap, built cheap curtis claims the fastest hookup... I dont think they can beet the boss RT3 hands down.
to sum it up:
Boss (straight poly RT3)
Western Pro (Uni-Mount Steel)
Meyer (Classic II steel)
Fisher (steel)
GET a "Fume Flap" (the rubber strip on the top of the plow that hangs down) It will reduce the "Fume"/ snow that comes over the plow, up the hood and on the windsheild when plowing above 10mph.
my . 02
Ian Coleman
Coleman Landscape Maint. & Snow Removal