Well, in short, I screwed up. The 6. 7 damper does indeed contact the 5. 9 fan pulley
#ad
You can see that it touches by the slightest bit.
Here's the 5. 9 damper and 6. 7 pulley:
#ad
6. 7 pulley:
#ad
#ad
5. 9 pulley:
#ad
#ad
Basically, I was more concerned with the actual mounting bracket as well as the size of the wheels; the thickness of each never even dawned on me. As you can see, the 6. 7 pulley is 1/4" thinner than the 5. 9 pulley, and this is what creates the clearance needed between the larger damper and the pulley. The 5. 9 pulley is 1 3/4" thick vs. 1 1/2" thick for the 6. 7 pulley. I apologize for the mistake.
Here is the 5. 9 damper held in front of the 6. 7 damper:
#ad
I was able to pull the 5. 9 damper off, and of course I started to round one of the bolt heads on the 6. 7 damper, so I said screw it and didn't mess with it anymore. The only weight I got for the 5. 9 damper was 14. 8 lbs, which may or may not be accurate. The only scale I have is a joke bathroom scale that I can't seem to get to work
It flashed zeros at me 5 times and the only number I managed to get was when I pushed on it some and got the 14. 8...
The 6. 7 damper is 9 9/16" across.
The 5. 9 damper is 8 3/4" across.
Hopefully this clears up the mystery (5. 9 damper/5. 9 pulley. 6. 7 damper/6. 7 pulley)


You can see that it touches by the slightest bit.
Here's the 5. 9 damper and 6. 7 pulley:

6. 7 pulley:


5. 9 pulley:


Basically, I was more concerned with the actual mounting bracket as well as the size of the wheels; the thickness of each never even dawned on me. As you can see, the 6. 7 pulley is 1/4" thinner than the 5. 9 pulley, and this is what creates the clearance needed between the larger damper and the pulley. The 5. 9 pulley is 1 3/4" thick vs. 1 1/2" thick for the 6. 7 pulley. I apologize for the mistake.
Here is the 5. 9 damper held in front of the 6. 7 damper:

I was able to pull the 5. 9 damper off, and of course I started to round one of the bolt heads on the 6. 7 damper, so I said screw it and didn't mess with it anymore. The only weight I got for the 5. 9 damper was 14. 8 lbs, which may or may not be accurate. The only scale I have is a joke bathroom scale that I can't seem to get to work

The 6. 7 damper is 9 9/16" across.
The 5. 9 damper is 8 3/4" across.
Hopefully this clears up the mystery (5. 9 damper/5. 9 pulley. 6. 7 damper/6. 7 pulley)