Originally posted by AndyMan
I definately don't want to risk putting you at odds with another shop, but question the single pump statement... SO, why would adding a pusher pump to my existing set up be a bad thing? Gimmie some suggestions bud!!! What can I do to keep my starving my precious CP3?
Well it may put us at odds, but we're all gentlemen here and can recognize that each vendor has developed a solution that may indeed solve the problem.
We like single pump rigs for a variety of reasons:
1) Simplicity. 1 pump, no external bypasses or additional filters. Less to go wrong, easier to hook up.
2) When pressure starts to drop, you know where the culprit is. In dual pump settings, you've got two different sources of problems. Tack in regulators, bypasses, and additional filters and you've just added more things that can wrong.
3) Utility of the truck. I have by no means seen all the pusher pump assemblies on the market, however many of the ones I've seen end up sticking below the frame rail, or stuff the pump out in an open area. For those of who do drive off-road, this is bad news. Snow, stumps, rocks and little animals can all get to that pump assembly back there. We replace between 2 and 5 pusher assemblies a month around here because the rear mounted lift pump has gotten eaten out from rain or salt water impregnation. Probably not an issue if you live in a dry climate, but definitely bad news for those of who are snowbound 5 months of the year, or who have alot of rainfall.
4) A single pump is perfectly capable of pulling fuel that short distance, and indeed, the siphon effect from the tank is probably more than what the engine is even asking for. We haven't measured the siphon effect from an 03 yet, but on an 02, the siphon effect would drain a fuel tank in less than 15 minutes. Thats 120 GPH of siphon. On the 02 and unders, the only problem in the system was those restrictive lines after the lift anyway, so thats all you needed to address. On the 03, it appears to be a volume problem and a line problem.
5) Dual pump systems tend to be too high pressure. I know this is debatable, but we've seen VP44s that have failed due to excessive inlet pressure (our opinion verified by an indepedent pump shop). We don't know what the CP3 needs for inlet pressure, and can't find that information anywhere, but we feel there is a reason its set to 11. 5 PSI from the factory. So, if we can deliver all the volume that the CP3 wants, at stock pressure levels whether you are idling or at WOT, then I'd say we've got the problem nix'ed.
Our take on the situation is that we need a good single pump system, mounted under the hood again to keep it protected, and using lines that the pump was designed to use. The FASS system looks sweet, as we won't need to worry about a custom machined fitting to mount on the fuel filter canister. But it is awful high pressure. Maybe an external regulator would work on it, but the system wasn't designed to be used with one. We're looking into that critter, as well as other heavy duty pumps from other manufacturers. Its going to be awhile. The 02 fuel systems taught us a bunch, but we've got some unknowns here that we need to play with.