I have them on the back of my Gemtop Contractor canopy. The canopy sits about 2 ft above the cab and it has 'meatcleaver' styling. I've noticed about 1/2 mpg increase (16. 5 > 17. 0). But, I need to add up all my fillups to really get an accurate number.
The road spray used to cover both lanes and part of the ditch behind my truck. It looked like I was driving a boat with a large wake. I could back up the tailgators by just driving through a puddle. With the Airtabs I have no road spray visible out the back. I can drive through water and the tailgators just hang in behind me. (One just tried to drive under, but the hitch stopped her). So, this alone convinced me they were working. If my truck is not disturbing the air 20 feet on both sides it must make a differance.
Cross winds don't effect the steering as much any more with the airtabs.
One drawback, the original white color matched my truck and canopy exactly when I installed them. Now after about two years they are turning yellow. I'd recomend that you paint them, even if it is white. If you put these on a curved surface, water and dirt will get underneath, so seal them with clear rtv on the edges.
How well these work depends on each application. Mine would work better if I had a better wing on the front, so the air coming over the top would be smoother. On long trailers, length over 3x the width or height, these should work very well.
I work at a hi-tech firm. I get about one question per week on the airtabs. It is really funny to explain what these are supposed to do, half of the 'engineers' don't get it. Lots of the 'high school grads' do get it. All of the hot rodders and motorcyclist get it. Guess you can be educated beyond your intelligence.