Don,
Did you use to be registered under another user name? Your tone sounds very familiar!
Basically, DC, Standard transmission, Joe, you, and some others keep saying over and over again about the heat problem. The GL-5 additives will attack the soft metals in the synchros.
All I am saying is this:
I called Amsoil about the warning label. They said we are rated GL-2 to GL-5, plus MT-1. This lube is safe for this transmission.
People have been using it in these transmissions since 1994. (this was in 98)
I drained the Castrol at 26,000 miles. It was burnt up, thick, and generally disgusting. And DC tells you to run it 100,000!!!
In goes the Amsoil, one change until 88,000. Clutch failure led me to shift without the clutch, burning 3rd synchro out.
I went to Enterprise Engine to have it fixed, plus the fully splined mainshaft. (Never had the 5th problem, my shaft was PERFECT, but changed any way, BOMB up, right?)
(BTW,
I went to Enterprise over buying a rebuilt unit from Standard for 2 reasons: One, Standard said they only change parts if they are wore enough in their rebuilds, I knew mine was taken of, I justed needed a part or two. Perhaps this explains their short warranty? Just my opinion, no facts.
Two, Mitchell was closer, and an excellent clutch installer. )
I went in there, fully prepared to eat crow, if it looked bad, and announce to the TDR Joe was right, I was wrong.
Trust me, if the Amsoil was causing damage, it would have been drained.
They opened it up, and wow, it is the BEST looking guts they had ever seen. NO soft metal damage, no excessive heat marks, very little dirt at all.
They specialize in Dodge 5 and 6 speeds,(and 5. 9 POWER) and I compared parts while I was there. Lots of mangled burnt up synchros that were running Syntorq.
Steve came in next day with his properly maintained Castrol unit, for a clutch and 5th update,. Opened it up, burnt looking oil.
Radixr came after that, for a clutch, 5th update, with an Amsoil unit, again, SUPER, SUPER, clean, no damage.
This is a rotten deal by DC, and I feel strongly about it, not because I sell Amsoil, but because I own a Cummins, and I do not like to be ripped off.
DC can sell Castrol at $5 a qt, and still double their money.
I will leave the "science" to Joe, I have no "tests" to prove Amsoil is better in this case, all I have is my common sense and my eyes.
You fellas run what you want, but please, don't try the scare tactics DC likes to use on the new guys.
Some of us don't get scared by big corporations.
Joe,
I really didn't mean to offend you. Oops. Yes, your tests are very scientific, they just don't mean anything!
I have decided to review your past articles, and do a little "THIS IS YOUR LIFE JOE!" article.
I think it would fun for the whole family to read!
Mr. Fast,
How about finned covers?
Gene