Here I am

Transmission Buyers (Caveat Emptor)

Attention: TDR Forum Junkies
To the point: Click this link and check out the Front Page News story(ies) where we are tracking the introduction of the 2025 Ram HD trucks.

Thanks, TDR Staff

Latest auto trans thread

New shocks

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let the buyer beware!

I have had 4 transmissions since owning my dodge. Stock, Dunrite TC & VB, ATS stageIV, and currently DTT.



Here's an objective viewpoint of what I have noticed.

Stock: slipped as soon as an upgrade in power was made.

Dunrite: At the power I had the VB was O. K. but the TC was not able to do the job.

ATS: (this is going to be long there's alot of info here. ) I had intermittent problems with the Dunrite upgrade and could not get it to perform correctly. However with the problems I had, was unsure if it was the upgrade I had done or something else in the transmission. Because of this and the resources I had, I chose to go with a stage IV ATS to resolve all my current problems and any future problems that may occur from increasing to more rwhp.

With this in mind the bolt on installation of the ATS went easily after we finally received the order and the transmission was better than anything stock and even better than the Dunrite upgrade I had before it.

I was running about 350-400 rwhp. I had DD3's, DD UFM drag chip, B1 turbo, 4"exhaust, and LPG.

The ATS torque converter itself was similar to driving stock around town. Its efficientcy was mediocre at best and there was a tremendous difference in rpm drop when it would lock from fluid coupling. I could not lock the TC without barking the B1 in 2nd or 3rd. That's how big of an rpm drop there was when it locked up. I noticed it was very easy to drive around town because it did not pull the engine down at all. It was represented to me that all my future needs for rwhp would be met with this unit and that something else would break before this unit would go out. They sold me on the lock up clutches and the increased forward clutches which were represented to be 5 and the special VB that came with the stage IV.

Here's where the fun begins:

Sent my truck up north to be modified. They took out the transmission to do my mods after 8-9 months of ownership and the forward clutches were toasted in 3rd gear. Upon further inspection of the interior of the unit: 4 clutch pack (supposed to be 5) Factory stock apply lever 3. 8 ratio, 727 stock band, factory band strut, factory sealing rings, and that special VB--a transgo shift kit!

I was very unhappy! In speaking to the owner of ATS he neither denied or refuted these facts, but instead tried to twist the facts of our initial conversation to his benefit. After several heated conversations with C(owner) ATS. The seller of said unit (ATS) tried to take my place as victim and subjectively put all the resposposibility of breakdown on me as consumer when I never ever abused the transmission at all. It was agreed between us that he would replace the unit under warranty.

It took over 12 weeks of downtime to get a warranty replacement unit. Meanwhile back at ATS there were several sponsored customers who had broken down months after me and had their new unit within a week!!! I know because I saw them post on this site.

If I would have had enough time to wait I most likely would have taken my beating and installed the warranty unit. But I couldn't wait that long and decided to have a new DTT installed.

Here's what I have noticed about DTT in contrast:

I bought a 91R TC. VERY efficient. You put this thing in gear and you know the majority of engine power is going to the ground. When it enters lockup there is not much difference between lockup and fluid coupling. A drop of 125 rpm at most; in 2nd even less. Lock to lock shifts can be done but for all out longevity not recommended for all applications. This transmission is considerably different from ATS. It tranfers much more to the ground, holds lockup just as good if not better. The VB shifts are better than before and I now have the peace of mind knowing that this transmission will serve me well because all the interior parts of the transmission body being upgraded. Seals, clutches, drums, pistons, shafts, bands, levers etc. nothing remained stock.

Installation went well and service so far has not been needed.

From my opinion and experience with these products I have found lockup to be a non issue. Here's what I mean. All the lockup clutches have held on all the transmissions except for the stock TC. Usually before lockup fails on these aftermarket transmissions, something else breaks. Things go out like the forward clutches will slip before lockup breaks loose, or the input or output shafts could break, maybe the flex plate from lock to lock shifts, whatever. My point is that the big sales sales pitch of having a huge lockup surface is only as good as its weakest link. Before the lockup fails on nearly any of the aftermarket transmissions, something else is sure to fail in the body of the transmission.

CAVEAT EMPTOR ( let the buyer beware) Don't always believe a sales pitch. It may sound good but is not always true. Don't take what a sponsored driver is saying as the gospel. The borrower is the slave to the lender. I personally have heard of all sorts of transmission problems regarding sponsored people and they will act as if nothing is ever wrong. I paid full retail for the ATS and the DTT and don't owe any of them anything.

Hopefully this will save someone the aggravation and the money of making the same mistakes I did.

And by the way that ATS warranty unit. They billed me for it. !! Shipping both ways, an upgraded input shaft, and a HUGE core charge. Not to mention the installation I will have to pay for if I put it in. I had another heated conversation with C(ATS) owner and he said that if I send back the core he would give me a -0- invoice showing paid. I had to really fight for that. I don't like or condone this type of stonewalling from the Manufacturer because it takes all the fun out my hobby.

Picked up a copy of their(ATS) warranty in writing and read it over. Everything in it is subjective! Basically if they don't like the way you dress you could be out of luck!
 
Last edited:
WOW :eek: ... ... ... . One heck of a first post Dude.

Welcome :D



Now pulling up a lawn chair, poping the top on a chilled adult beverage, and waiting for the show.
 
Last edited:
Feeling good!

Welcome and thanks for your post. I have felt really good about my decision to go with DTT and Bill Kondolay and your post just reinforces my feelings. It's been almost a year now and I am very happy with the install. My truck is a pleasure to drive now - I go out of my way just to drive it. I suspect that you have purchased the last transmission for your truck. And if you do have problems down the line Bill Kondolay and crew will be there for you. Regards. Lynn Schwartz.
 
Current mods: 24V p-pump conversion by Piers, ported head by Piers with Mitchell twins and Mitchell cam.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your input. You have been through a lot from what you said. Man, you have spent a PILE of money on transmissions. I hope this one does all that you want.



IF the BS childish ranting (on ALL SIDES!!) can stay out of this thread MAYBE some valuable information can be gained, as I expect a statement will be made by ATS. If both sides of this can present their case reasonably (one has already) we will all have information to use in our own decisions. I really hope the cheerleaders for both DTT and ATS go home, put the pom-poms away, and come to this thread as adults.
 
LSmith, I'm with you, I'm already saving my $$$ for a DTT setup. This just re-enforces my decision.

I've learned a great deal from the discussions on the transmission-War threads, I've just seen too many of these transmission threads erupt, and usually someone's gone in the end.
 
Actually Shovelhead, I am in dire need of a transmission and have not decided who to go with. My transmission is begging for mercy, but I am not giving any LOL.



If the emotion by parties that have already made their bed can be left out we will all learn more. It is that unchecked emotion that hinders us when we try to learn.
 
WHAT cabrokr SAID

For Those who do not have a DTT unit - its' hard to understand - that lock-up is no big deal. The high heat is a bunch of bull. I pulled my 5er (25K GCW) to WV in summer. Highest temp was 167. Less than stock, 180-190. So go figure. If mine went out tomorrow I'd put a nuther one in - its just that good. I never relized how bad the stock 47re is until I got the DTT upgrade.



Thank you



George
 
There was a rant- on some other past transmission thread- That these "new transmissions" are just a good rebuild with some specialty parts. Well I thought everyone understood that. Even top fuel started out with stock hemi motors and a specialty fuel system and rebuild. Bill Knodwdly (-5 spelling ) Was essentially thrown off for starting wars and calling into question certain advertisements of competitors that seemed to bother him. We lost his knowledge here and are poorer for it. I do not believe that a vendor should be hounded for his view on the way to tune and build a transmission. They should all have customer service/ honesty at the root of thier business. Some vendors may claim that thier system gets 600 RWHP to the ground in lockup without problerms. Some claim that this is asking for trouble, and that the fluid coupling of the TC should be used to lessen the shock loads on the rest of the drive line. Each method may have compromises. Loss of WOT performance when out of lockup, Breakage of other parts in a tight lockup. Time will tell. Which one is good for racing and which one will last the longest. For the first go to the time slips. For the second time and customer experience will tell.
 
Last edited:
*******************************

Try to keep this thread on track guys. Keep it to the facts as it is so far and everyone will benefit. No mud slinging, cheer leading, etc.



Sorry to hear about all your troubles cabrokr and I hope don't have any further problems.



-Steve St. Laurent

Lead Moderator
 
cabrokr, sorry to hear about all of your transmission problems. How about a thread about your p-pumped truck? I would like to know you honest opinions on the conversion as I've been thinking about doing the same on a 24V truck. It sounds like you have a real nice engine/transmission combination now.
 
Originally posted by johnrv4

cabrokr, sorry to hear about all of your transmission problems. How about a thread about your p-pumped truck? I would like to know you honest opinions on the conversion .



Same here.
 
I wonder if I have a bum transmission. I have the DTT 91% and hit 230 on the cooler line out of the transmission in unlock towing 6 calves and a 20 ft bumper pull stock trailer. This is the highest I have ever seen. It is about a 3 mile pull at around 7%. Had to go in second gear real slow following a big truck. I think that had ALOT to do with it. It still created more heat than I like.





I am just trying to state that I have seen temps in the 180 range driving around town and once up to 200 while leaving it in drive going through the drive through at Rotten Ronnies. Mine does create heat..... but it is not a problem as far as I can tell.





On the second trip though, I kept the transmission locked up in OD and let her buck up the hill. Transmission temps stayed around 160 and the cows went up the hill so fast that when I opened the door to let them out at the auction... ... they were all standing in the far corner of the stock trailer with their hooves over their eyes because they have never went so fast in their lives! :D :D :D





Amsoil Universal ATF... ... ... ...
 
Swamp Donkey,



When your transmission guy set up your truck it does not sound like he took out the one way flow valve from the cooler line going up to the heat exchanger.
 
re: ATS warranty unit.

I attribute the help of an ATS sponsored member for getting ATS to send the warranty unit. Without his help I doubt that it would have ever came at all. His calling and prompting them helped tremendously.

This is not a hard luck story..... The mods I currently have on my truck go above and beyond what most people do. . ie, balanced crank, rods, fly cut pistons. Ceramic coated pistons all balanced for peak performance. Custom injector lines and fuel system with 10AN steel braided from the tank to the pump, 6AN return lines. Piers Stoopid p-pump. O ringed block and head with . 010 over copper head gasket. My fueling system is on a regulator so it delivers 30 psi at idle and 30psi WOT . It is setup to support extremely high horsepower. Mitchell custom lifters, pushrods and much more, its easier to list what was not done because the list goes on. If you are interested email me. -- email address removed --
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Swamp Donkey

I got up to 200 once in SNOXVILLE, TN, 2hours to get through. That creeping along is bad. I also have a transmission coller with fan mounted under frame by transmission. If temp on return line is 180 it kicks on. Don't do that much.



Dem cows must have been scared:) Better watch out for the animal rights folks:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top