Yep, This is a fun discussion. Yet we are talking, as much, about each others needs, as much as the rifle's capabilities. But, the rifle MUST have better than MOA capability for this scenerio. There are places in Colorado where Elk are on your doorstep and a large bore revolver would work just fine as a tool to dispatch one of these big meat bags. My Dads . 300 Savage, does this quite well with iron sights. Then there are places where the Elk are 1/4 mile or more away, across open wheat fields and will run into the next county at the first quiver of the locoweed. Dont fergit, the landowners rules that there will be no gutpiles in the wheat! Then there are the neighbors that hate hunters. The requirement is that the elk drops in its footprints. No chasing blood trails. One shot, one kill, OOOHHHHAAAAAA
. The target is not the elk, but a spot on the elk that is the conduit for all the nerve impulses that drive those huge and tasty muscles. That target is, ideally, at the base of the ear. It does extend down the neck but it is only about 3" wide. I dont trophy hunt so there is no issue here, nor do I wish to wound and not recover an animal. Practice with precise bullet placement and range estimation is crutial to a successful outcome.
I use a head and neck sillouette target and the stepped crosshair on a 4. 5X14 Leupold scope to fine tune my capabilities. The rifle I assembled for this purpose is a heavy barrelled affair using a blueprinted Remington-700 Magnum Action, H-S precision barrel and stock. The cartridge is the old . 30-338 with a tight neck. Ammo is loaded using hand dies. Necks are turned for concentricity, primer pockets are cut flat and square and the flash holes are chamfered. Am I picky? YEP! If I do my part, this combination can take an alert Cow Elk out to 600 yards. The longest shot, for me is 500 yards(Witnessed). ( Lets not mention varmint rifles and the long range possibilities, thereOo. :-laf. )
Personally, Accuracy and precision, in a rifle is the epitome of the science. Souped up diesel trucks are cool, but 5 shots in 1 1/2" at 1000 yards makes me drool:-laf
Oo. . GregH

I use a head and neck sillouette target and the stepped crosshair on a 4. 5X14 Leupold scope to fine tune my capabilities. The rifle I assembled for this purpose is a heavy barrelled affair using a blueprinted Remington-700 Magnum Action, H-S precision barrel and stock. The cartridge is the old . 30-338 with a tight neck. Ammo is loaded using hand dies. Necks are turned for concentricity, primer pockets are cut flat and square and the flash holes are chamfered. Am I picky? YEP! If I do my part, this combination can take an alert Cow Elk out to 600 yards. The longest shot, for me is 500 yards(Witnessed). ( Lets not mention varmint rifles and the long range possibilities, thereOo. :-laf. )
Personally, Accuracy and precision, in a rifle is the epitome of the science. Souped up diesel trucks are cool, but 5 shots in 1 1/2" at 1000 yards makes me drool:-laf
