It's really hard to gauge, with any kind of accuracy, DEF consumption, by re-filling 2.5 gallons at a time. If you're pulling a 4-car trailer, that in itself would limit the fuel retailers where you could buy fuel. I'd thought you would be buying bulk at the pump......due to DEF cost savings as well as the ease of negotiating your truck & trailer for fuel purchases.
DEF consumption is easily calculated by filling it all the way up, then re-filling at the pump, with total gallons used (just like hand-calculating fuel economy)
600/2.5= 240 MPG of DEF......that's definitely on the low side.
I would agree. * And add that the highly inaccurate gauge adds to the complication of knowing def use/consumption*